Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Abbot against the world...
Collapse
X
-
Article V meeting of the states to force an amendment. A little known clause the federal government (and left) doesn't want you to know."When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic." -Benjamin Franklin
"A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover that they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury." -Alexander Fraser Tytler
Comment
-
There is a lot I agree with but I need to see some more details. For instance, there are times that deficit spending is going to be needed (like wartime) so I need to see the details and exceptions behind that proposal.
However I'm dead set against number 6 requiring a super majority from the court to overturn a democratically enacted law. We would still have Jim Crow laws if this were the law of the land back in the 50s.
All that said, I think everyone should carefully consider the ramifications of a full on Constitutional Convention. That convention wouldn't be limited to the "Texas Plan" everything is up for grabs. You could see a real attempt to amend or repeal the 2nd amendment or other parts of the Bill of Rights. You could even end up with a new Constitution...
Do you really want to risk it?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Sgt Beavis View Post
However I'm dead set against number 6 requiring a super majority from the court to overturn a democratically enacted law. We would still have Jim Crow laws if this were the law of the land back in the 50s.
All that said, I think everyone should carefully consider the ramifications of a full on Constitutional Convention. That convention wouldn't be limited to the "Texas Plan" everything is up for grabs. You could see a real attempt to amend or repeal the 2nd amendment or other parts of the Bill of Rights. You could even end up with a new Constitution...
Do you really want to risk it?
You're not going to see the 2nd amendment repealed. The purpose of the convention, and the docket for the convention is established beforehand."When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic." -Benjamin Franklin
"A democracy will continue to exist up until the time that voters discover that they can vote themselves generous gifts from the public treasury." -Alexander Fraser Tytler
Comment
-
Originally posted by CJ View Post
You're not going to see the 2nd amendment repealed. The purpose of the convention, and the docket for the convention is established beforehand.
However it still requires 3/4ths of state legislatures to approve each amendments (or a hypothetical new constitution)
Comment
-
CJ is right, I believe. Now if they were calling on a convention for a new constitution we would have worries. What Wheels (and several other states who have voted in favor of a convention) have been in favor of is restricting the feds and empowering the states more. Not worried in that scenario about the bill of rights.I don't like Republicans, but I really FUCKING hate Democrats.
Sex with an Asian woman is great, but 30 minutes later you're horny again.
Comment
-
Also I believe there are about 27 who have voted in favor of a convention for a balanced budget amendment; 34 are needed to get a convention going. My understanding that is if 34 vote on that alone, then that is all they can work on. What the Professor has proposed should start that over as 34 would need to vote in favor of that proposal so they could tackle more than just the single issue voted on recently. I am no expert on this but that is the way I understand it.I don't like Republicans, but I really FUCKING hate Democrats.
Sex with an Asian woman is great, but 30 minutes later you're horny again.
Comment
Comment