Eli Manning Claims To Be A Top 5 QB??

[Geor!]

Fuck it. He's still an asshole.

[mstng86]

Fuck it. He's still an asshole.

Probably. But who isn't these days?

[SouthernSVT]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Tony Romo
7. Michael Vick
8. Matt Schuab
9. Ben Roethlisberger
10. Sam Bradford
11. Matthew Stafford
12. Matt Ryan
13. Joe Flacco
14. Josh Freeman
15. Mark Sanchez
16. Colt McCoy
17. Matt Hasselbeck
18. Kevin Kolb
19. Matt Cassell
20. Kyle Orton
21. Vince Young
22. Donovan McNabb
23. Ryan Fitzpatrick
24. Jay Cutler
25. David Garrard
26. Matt Moore
27. jason Campbell
28. Matt Flynn
29. Eli Manning

[pHILSANITY07]

IMO

1. Peyton Manning - Best QB of the 00's
2. Tom Brady - Best Playoff QB in the 00's
3. Drew Brees - One of the most accurate QB's
4. Aaron Rodgers - Very Accurate, also moblie
5. Big Ben - Hard to bring down, also good in clutch
6. Micheal Vick - A Threat from the air and ground now.
7. Philip Rivers - He's tough, and also has done well in the playoffs.
8. Tony Romo - When healthy he is Top 10, also good at moving around
9. Matt Ryan - Very good home record
10. Joe Flacco - 3 playoff appearances in his first 3 years.
11. Eli Manning - Either feast or famine, mainly famine as of late
12. Matt Cassell - Last year he showed why he is a starter in the NFL
13. Kyle Orton - One of the most underrated players, just look at his stats.
14. Matt Shaub - Question has always been health, but when healthy he can light it up.
15. Mark Sanchez - If he can get better as a passer, he can move up on this list.
16. Jay Culter - Cannon Arm, but isnt accurate. Bad Additude, also a quiter.
17. Jason Campbell - Very underrated, also not apprectiated in Washington
18. Donovan McNabb - 3 years ago he was Top 10, probably be outside of Top 20 after this year.
19. Sam Bradford - If he can get some weapons, he will move up on this list.
20. Josh Freeman - Quietly had a great softmore year in TB
21. Ryan Fitzpatrick - Very Underrated IMO
22. David Garrard -If the Jags can have talent around him he is pretty good.
23. Chad Henne - Honestly overrated.
24. Tavaris Jackson - Maybe learning from Favre will make him better in Seattle
25. Rex Grossman - Overrated
26. Kevin Kolb - We'll see if he is as good as everyone says he is.
27. Alex Smith - GTFO
28. Colt McCoy - If Cleveland can build around him he could be pretty good
29. Matthew Stafford - Has potential, if he can just stay healthy
30. Cam Newton - Overrated
31 Matt Hassellbeck - Once was a good QB, but can't stay healthy
32. Andy Dalton - Welcome to the NFL, now enjoy getting sacked

redid the list

[pHILSANITY07]

BTW, i did starting QB's not backups on that list

[Sgt Beavis]

Eli has been back in Louisiana sniffin' the swamp gas.

[idrivea4banger]

BTW, i did starting QB's not backups on that list

Thanks for clearing that up for us. I wasnt sure who they were.

[pHILSANITY07]

Thanks for clearing that up for us. I wasnt sure who they were.

nice sarcasam

[Machx2]

Eli belongs somewhere behind Kitna..

[Geor!]

nice sarcasam

Just do like I do and put that fucking idiot on ignore. Then you only have to worry about reading his bullshit when someone actually bothers replying to it.

[exlude]

3. Romo
4. Kitna
5. Mcgee / Sam Bradford tie

Romo at 3? lol

[slow99]

Romo at 3? lol

Uhhhhh

[bcoop]

I agree with Romo being around 8-9. Lmao @ Tony. I like to bring up that commercial every time he pulls an Eli.


Bradford as top 5? Lmfao. I'm a huge Bradford fan, but he isn't even worthy of being in the discussion after ONE pro season.

[pHILSANITY07]

I agree with Romo being around 8-9. Lmao @ Tony. I like to bring up that commercial every time he pulls an Eli.


Bradford as top 5? Lmfao. I'm a huge Bradford fan, but he isn't even worthy of being in the discussion after ONE pro season.

no, Bradford is outside Top 15 or 15th best right now, but he is moving up.

[Nash B.]

Uhhhhh

I got the joke!